Posts tagged as:

marketers

No Gravatar

I picked up a tweet from Jean-Philippe (JP) Maheu, CEO of Publicis Modem, about a great execution by Nike on a Facebook video.  I have a lot of respect for JP, having followed his career and hearing him speak several times, most recently at the last Kellogg School of Management Marketing Conference.

So, I naturally hit his link to the video to see how good this execution was.  I was instantly Shocked, however, to discover that the only way I could view this video was to FIRST click “LIKE” on the FB Fan Page.  Let me make this perfectly clear.

Nike made me commit to Liking their video BEFORE they let me see it.

Nike requiring users to click LIKE before they could view their video

Nike requiring users to click LIKE before they could view their video

So… I clicked “Like” and then was permitted to watch the video.  To Nike’s credit - it was a beautiful execution.  Once of the best I have ever seen.  A lot of time, thought and money went into creating this stellar “mini movie” and it is well worth the watch.  That being said, I would have certainly appreciated the option of clicking “Like” after I had a chance to view the movie.

What makes this even worse is the way Facebook auto-broadcasts your feelings to the world.  So my forced “Liking” of the Nike video was broadcast to all my friends.  Of course the folks at Nike knew this would happen - that’s why they did it.  They’re not stupid.  Maybe a little shady, but not stupid.

Message broadcast after Nike's trick

This is a classic example of a big company smoking the social  media bong and getting high on the power of the medium.  They then go out and break the rules like a bunch of underage kids taking their dad’s car out for a spin, hoping they don’t get busted by the cops.

Nike, consider yourselves Busted.

UPDATE: MAY 24, 2010

When I originally wrote this blog, I was under the impression that the “Like” was related specifically to the video…much because the video instructs you to click on “Like” in order to watch it.  The Like button actually is a standard Page feature found commonly around Facebook.

How does this change my outlook?  Well, it does change it a bit.  Had I realized this, I could have surfed around the Nike page a bit, determined if I Liked the page and then decided if I liked it enough to click on Like and see their video.  So, instead of Nike cheating, I would say they are actually being foolish.  They are actually deterring people from watching the video that they spent thousands to produce, as Wassan commented below - she would have just skipped the video and not clicked “Like”. It reminds me a little of the blog post I wrote about a company who wanted me to fill out a huge form in order to watch their commercial.

There is another piece, however, that is more shady.  Nike is not very forthcoming about what clicking “Like” does.  According to Paul Adams who commented on this blog, my clicking on Like now gives Nike the ability to push stuff through my News Feed.  Not sure if this is Nike being shady or Facebook privacy / security being poor… or both.

So…. I change my original position.  Nike is not Cheating, but they’re on the line.

{ 10 comments }

No Gravatar

ButlerAbout a year ago Butler University in Indiana had a social media superstar working in marketing and admissions.  This individual really put Butler on the map and in front of the curve.  The problem is that when this individual left Butler to start his own social media consulting firm, all that Social Media Equity walked right out the door.  He had inadvertently built his own brand on Butler’s dime. There was a transition attempt, but in reality, Butler really fell off the Social Media map.

What went wrong?

How can you avoid this same mistake?

The great thing about Social Media is that it’s personal.  The HARD thing about Social Media is that it’s personal!  People don’t want to tweet with a brand.  That is like going into a store and having a conversation with the Mannequin about how nicely she is dressed.  However, if you ignore the brand completely and put all the equity into the Person, then - just like Butler - they can walk out the door.

There is no silver bullet here as each company is different.  However, here are some ideas you can implement which will at least help you straddle this difficult problem.

Ryan Squire OSU Medical CenterIf you have a Social Media guru in house, you could have them combine their twitter with your brand.  A great example of this is Ryan Squire.  When Ryan used to tweet for NBC, his twitter handle was @NBCSquire.  He built up a large following under this name but when he left NBC for OSU Medical Center, the twitter account did not go with him.  He now tweets under OSUSquire, thus co-branding with Ohio State.  The upside of this method is (personal + brand) which ensures the brand can’t walk out the door.  The down side is the twitter accounts, although they don’t go with Ryan, are virtually worthless without him.

Bresnan Communications Twitter AccountAnother twitter example I have seen is at Bresnan Communications.  Bresnan’s customer service recently launched a twitter account called @JenatBresnan.  This account uses a characterture avatar.  What I really like about this is you still have a picture of a person, not a logo, so people are more likely to talk to this person.  However, it really is portable.  If Jen ever leaves Bresnan and Tracy takes over, she can still tweet under JenatBresnan, which would be much harder if the avatar was an actual photo of Jen.

Rock Star BloggerLastly - blogging.  Many times with Corporate blogs, the entire thing hinges on one person - the Rock Star.  If the Rock Star leaves, the blog is basically dead.  You may be able to transition the corporate blog to another writer, but the audience has developed a personal relationship with the Rock Star who just left so this transition will be rocky at best.

A good alternative to this is to have a multi-person blog where you have several writers.  In this situation people tend to follow the the “company” more than any individual blogger since each post could be from someone different.  Many PeepsIf you lose one of your bloggers, this is hardly noticeable at the corporate blog level and you can easily bring one or two new bloggers on board without disruption.

Again - there is no one-size-fits-all solution here.  My challenge to you is that when you go into a social media strategy that you do so with your head on straight - thinking through how you are going to balance “Personal” with “Brand”.  Don’t let your Social Media Brand walk out the door.

{ 5 comments }

Marketers walk the line between Social Media and Data Privacy

February 4, 2010

As a marketer, you dream of data.  With data you can deliver more relevant information.  You can deliver more timely information!  You can Micro-Market directly to those who are most likely to buy!
Which brings us to the issue of privacy.  You see, privacy and social  media are inherently at odds with one another.  Marking [...]

Read the full article →